PRESS RELEASE -

Social media manipulation by political actors now an industrial scale problem prevalent in over 80 countries – annual Oxford report

The manipulation of public opinion through social media remains a growing threat to democracies around the world, according to the 2020 media manipulation survey from the Oxford Internet Institute, part of the University of Oxford.

The report reveals that organized social media manipulation campaigns operate in 81 countries, up from 70 countries in 2019, with global misinformation being produced on an industrial scale by major governments, public relations firms and political parties. It describes how disinformation has become a common strategy of cyber manipulation, with more than 76 of the 81 countries deploying disinformation as part of political communication.

Professor Philip Howard, Director of the Oxford Internet Institute, and the report’s co-author says: “Our report shows misinformation has become more professionalised and is now produced on an industrial scale. Now more than ever, the public needs to be able to rely on trustworthy information about government policy and activity. Social media companies need to raise their game by increasing their efforts to flag misinformation and close fake accounts without the need for government intervention, so the public has access to high-quality information.”

The OII team says the level of social media manipulation has soared since 2019, with governments and political parties spending millions on private sector ‘cyber troops’, who drown out other voices on social media. Such professional cyber troops have also used citizen influencers to spread manipulated messages. These include volunteers, youth groups and civil society organisations, who support their ideologies.

OII alumna, Dr Samantha Bradshaw, the report’s lead author says, “Our 2020 report highlights the way in which government agencies, political parties and private firms continue to use social media to spread political propaganda, polluting the digital information ecosystem and suppressing freedom of speech and freedom of the press. A large part of this activity has become professionalized, with private firms offering disinformation-for-hire services.”

Key findings the OII researchers identified include:

• Private ‘strategic communications’ firms are playing an increasing role in spreading computational propaganda, with researchers identifying state actors working with such firms in 48 countries.
• Almost $60 million has been spent on firms who use bots and other amplification strategies to create the impression of trending political messaging.
• Social media has become a major battleground, with firms such as Facebook and Twitter taking steps to combat ‘cyber troops’, while some $10 million has been spent on social media political advertisements. The platforms removed more than 317,000 accounts and pages from ‘cyber troops’ actors between January 2019 and November 2020.

Cyber troops are frequently directly linked to state agencies, according to the report, “In 62 countries, we found evidence of a government agency using computational propaganda to shape public attitudes.”

But established political parties were also found to be using social media to ‘spread disinformation, suppress political participation, and undermine oppositional parties’, say the Oxford researchers.

According to the report, “In 61 countries, we found evidence of political parties or politicians running for office who have used the tools and techniques of computational propaganda as part of their political campaigns. Indeed, social media has become a critical component of digital campaigning.”

Dr Bradshaw adds: “Cyber troop activity can look different in democracies compared to authoritarian regimes. Electoral authorities need to consider the broader ecosystem of disinformation and computational propaganda, including private firms and paid influencers, who are increasingly prominent actors in this space.”

About the Report

1. The 2020 report draws upon a four-step methodology employed by Oxford researchers to identify evidence of globally organised manipulation campaigns. This includes a systematic content analysis of news articles on cyber troop activity, a secondary literature review of public archives and scientific reports, generating country specific case studies and expert consultations. The research work was carried out by Oxford researchers between 2019-2020. Computational Propaganda project research studies are published at https://demtech.oii.ox.ac.uk/publications/
2. The report explores the tools and techniques of computational propaganda, including the use of fake accounts – bots, humans and hacked accounts – to spread disinformation.  It finds:

• • 79 countries used human accounts
  • 57 counties used bot accounts
  • 14 countries used hacked or stolen accounts

3. Researchers examined how cyber troops use different communication strategies to manipulate public opinion, such as creating disinformation or manipulated media, data-driven targeting and employing abusive strategies such as mounting smear campaigns or online harassment. The report finds:

• • 76 countries used disinformation and media manipulation as part of their campaigns
  • 30 countries used data-drive strategies to target specific users with political advertisements.
  • 59 countries used state sponsored trolls to attack political opponents or activists in 2019, up from 47 countries in 2019

The University of Oxford

Oxford University has been placed number 1 in the Times Higher Education World University Rankings for the fifth year running, and at the heart of this success is our ground-breaking research and innovation. Oxford is world-famous for research excellence and home to some of the most talented people from across the globe. Our work helps the lives of millions, solving real-world problems through a huge network of partnerships and collaborations. The breadth and interdisciplinary nature of our research sparks imaginative and inventive insights and solutions.